Epidemiological blunder in recent Gallup-Healthways State-by-State poll of obesity

Whatever the issue, state rankings make for popular news headlines. This state is the most/least fit. That state is the most/least obese.

Such was the case for a recent report by Gallop – Healthways, which has tracked adult obesity prevalence in the US for several years now. As a polling organization, Gallup provides some very helpful data on the state of public opinion on particular issues. In the case of their State of American Well-Being, they also collected height and weight information of respondents to calculate BMI.

The state-by-state breakdown of obesity in the US is somewhat helpful, showing where it clusters geographically and how individual states have fared over time (see figure).

obesity by stateBut the biggest shocker with this report has nothing to do with the rankings. It’s much more basic than that; an elementary epidemiological blunder.

They mistakenly use “incidence” when they really mean “prevalence.” Now, these terms sound similar, but they mean very different things when it comes to epidemiological studies.

Definitions

  • Incidence – a measure of change from non-disease to disease (which is the numerator) in a “population-at-risk” (which is the denominator) over a specific time period. In basic terms, incidence is often expressed as [Newly diagnosed cases] divided by [population-at-risk (or person-time-at-risk)].
  • Prevalence – a static measure of the proportion of a population that is diseased, whether the disease cases occurred recently or at some time in the past. Prevalence is expressed as [Existing cases] divided by [total population].

Unfortunately, the Gallup-Healthways data on obesity trends use these terms interchangeably. For example, this is the chart in the most recent report launched earlier this week. Notice it uses incidence in the tile.

national incidence of obesityThe data are, however, exactly the same as those previously reported by Gallup. The data below are from a poll released in January of this year. These data are portrayed as prevalence of adults within each of the three different weight categories. Look at the obesity trend line. Look familiar?

American adults by weight categoryThe Gallup-Healthways project is a helpful data source that provides some interesting insights into well-being in the US. I hope in future reports they will be a bit more cautious when it comes to characterizing data. Though the average reader may not pick up on the nuances of epidemiological research and data, it still matters. Using the appropriate language to accurately describe data is an easy way to help ensure research integrity in the future.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s